Update on discount airlines – the verdict
Just about a month and a half ago, I was sitting in my hotel in Manchester just after arriving into the UK from Tel Aviv. I started a 3-week trip back to Jersey and Gran Canaria.
To kick off the travel blog fest, I did a blog on discount airlines since I was going to be taking quite a number of them over the course of the 3 weeks. During that time, I flew with 2 discount airlines – Jet2.com & BMIBaby.
So the burning question is….what was the verdict? Are the discount airlines a friend or a foe? Are they really any cheaper than a standard commercial airline once you add up all the costs? We’ll soon find out.
For my Tel Aviv to Manchester trek, there was no other option than to fly discount a la Jet2.com. For my Manchester to Jersey flight via BMIBaby also the only other option was another discount airline, Flybe.
As I digress, let’s take what we can get.
What I will do is show the pros and cons of flying discount by 5 variables and rank them all out of 5:
1) Convenience – good route and access
2) Availability – how often do they fly the route, did I need to stay over at all
3) Hidden fees – check in, excess baggage
4) Costs on board – costs for food
5) Service – always one of my faves
6) Value for money – is this discount airline worth it?
Well, here’s what I found throughout my 6-leg journey – YES 6 legs – with the 2 airlines:
JET2.COM (4/6 legs of my trip) – Overall rating 4/5
Leg 1 – Tel Aviv to Manchester, Leg 4 – Manchester to Gran Canaria, Leg 5 – Gran Canaria to Manchester & Leg 6 – Manchester to Tel Aviv
Convenience (5/5) – very convenient route for me as I wanted to go in and out of Manchester from Tel Aviv as that gave me the opportunity to skip the transfer from Heathrow to Gatwick (no flights operate from Heathrow to Jersey anymore)
Availability (2/5) – the route from Tel Aviv to Manchester only operates on Thursday and Monday. It gets into Manchester quite late on the Thursday night so I had to stay over before I caught my flight to Jersey the next morning. On the way back I ended up having to wait until Monday morning to fly back to Tel Aviv so I had an additional 2 nights in Manchester post Gran Canaria. The Gran Canaria availability was fine but that was largely because we were on a package holiday.
Hidden fees (3/5) – they do charge for online check in (which I still can’t understand) but the baggage limit is 22 kg when you book with Jet2.com so its quite forgiving compared to other discount airlines. Also they aren’t so insane about the 1 hand baggage policy either – thank goodness. I paid a bit of excess baggage on our way to Gran Canaria but it was quite minimal (I think 20 GBP) so I can’t complain.
Costs on board (5/5) – snacks and drinks are priced reasonably so a tea break is always an option.
Service (5/5) – I found the check in staff very nice in Tel Aviv, Manchester and Gran Canaria and the crew on board was great too.
Value for money (4/5) - Pretty decent value for money and I would fly with them again. The planes were clean and service was good. Flying in and out of Manchester was better than London in my opinion so I think it was worth the money all in all.
BMI BABY (2/6 legs of my trip) – Overall rating 1/5
Leg 2 – Manchester to Jersey, Leg 2 – Jersey to Manchester
Convenience (4/5) – it is a convenient route as I needed to fly in and out of Manchester to Jersey.
Availability (3/5) – they operate one flight a day – at all sorts of hours of the day. A bit confusing but I guess variety is the spice of life.
Hidden fees (0/5) – this is where BMI Baby loses the plot. You must pay for your checked baggage – 30 pounds return! This paid baggage is only for 18 kgs I learned. I had 21 so ended up paying an extra 50 pounds to get over to Jersey – a flight of 45 minutes! Also you have to pay for checking in online – again 30 pounds. Unfortunately I got stung with this both ways so I am not going to fly with these guys again. Also on my way over to Jersey they were enforcing a strict 1 hand baggage policy – I even had to throw out my Tupperware container – I kid you not! This is not for the faint hearted…BEWARE!
Costs on board (3/5) – out of principle after my little extra baggage fees, I would not dare buy anything but the snacks and drinks looked a bit pricier than good old Jet2.com – why am I not surprised?
Service (0/5) – again a very poor showing by BMI Baby. The people at the check-in look like they are in misery land and I don’t blame them since they are the bearer of the 18kg bad news. Also I am a member of the Star Alliance (which BMI is a member of) and so I asked if I would be able to collect miles for my flight with BMI Baby and the gentleman (if we can call him that) laughed at me and said why would BMI Baby allow you to collect miles – we’re not affiliated with BMI! Sorry to ask silly questions when BMI is actually apart of the name BMI Baby – I guess I got a dose of the silly stick! Anyway, I learned my lesson for next time. If I ever am forced to fly with the likes of BMI Baby I’ll make sure to keep my mouth shut.
Value for money (1/5) - no way Jose! This airline won’t be geting my business anytime soon! I haven’t calculated how much my short flight to Jersey actually cost in the end (partly because I’m afraid it will exceed the price of my holiday for 2 weeks in the Canaries) but I must say its really disappointing that an airline like this can even operate the skies. As a marketer, there has to be a company that has better customer service that can help us travellers out. Having lived in Jersey, I know the options are limited but, come on, it’s got to get better than this.
The verdict – BMI Baby is definitely a miss but Jet2.com is worth a try!
So, in summary, how do I feel about discount airlines? Hmmm…I think that they have their place. As I said in my post in June, I’m willing to take them if they make my trip somehow more convenient – like Jet2.com did with giving me the Manchester option. The advantage of not having to go through London was ideal so if I needed something like that again I’d go for it. All airlines these days offer their challenges and as the Travelling Starfish that I am. I need to be aware that even with the best of airlines there is always room for problems.
The next flight I’m taking is with British Airways and we all know what can happen with these guys. I want you all to cross your fingers that in early Sept we’ll be nice and strike free!
For now, if you are tempted to hit the skies with a discount airline, do your research in order to make sure you are truly getting the deal you think you are!!
Enjoy, Miriam
